Reviews and Comments

Fionnáin

fionnain@bookwyrm.social

Joined 3 years, 6 months ago

I arrange things into artworks, including paint, wood, plastic, raspberry pi, people, words, dialogues, arduino, sensors, web tech, light and code.

I use words other people have written to help guide these projects, so I read as often as I can. Most of what I read is literature (fiction) or nonfiction on philosophy, art theory, ethics and technology.

Also on Mastodon.

This link opens in a pop-up window

Annie Ernaux, Tanya Leslie: Shame (Paperback, 2023, Fitzcarraldo Editions) 2 stars

An event that lived

2 stars

Annie Ernaux explains how shame has influenced her life in a short memoir. It begins with the climax: 'My father tried to kill my mother one Sunday in June, in the early afternoon'. From there, Ernaux explores her rural childhood in a post-war French village, and how this event and the fear of community shame stayed with her even nearly 50 years later.

It's hard to criticise something so personal, but the language is a little mechanical, perhaps because of the numbness created over time. It is also hard to understand the motivation for the book being published (I often feel this with memoirs so it may be my bias), but it did paint an interesting picture of a community that lived on gossip and thus hid their lives, something I have seen in my own life.

Rachel O'Dwyer: Tokens (2023, Verso Books) 5 stars

Platform capitalism is coming for the money in your pocket

Wherever you look, money is …

Value reimagined

5 stars

In Tokens, Rachel O'Dwyer tells a story of value through tokens, alternative objects of payment that operate outside of legal currencies. The book blends years of in-depth research with clever use of anecdote and a well considered structure of 9 chapters, each telling a different part of the story.

While the overarching theme of the book deals with contemporary digital technologies such as NFT artworks or video game trading currencies, there is plenty of room given to histories and cultures of tokens than just these recent phenomena. O'Dwyer blends art history, economics, feminist theory and technology to present tokens in everything from subversive economies to hyper-capitalist systems. Brilliantly written throughout, and overloaded with information that is a testament to a long and thoughtful research practice.

Cormac McCarthy: The Passenger (Hardcover, 2022, Knopf) 4 stars

Nominee for Best Historical Fiction (2022) 1980, PASS CHRISTIAN, MISSISSIPPI: It is three in the …

What else?

4 stars

The best moments in Cormac McCarthy's last novel are dialogues that thread out different philosophies. They mingle the threat of nuclear war with fear of surveillance, weang physics and mathematics with literature and drama. It feels like a culmination of McCarthy's life's work, with thoughts on violence, friendship and major moments in 20th Century US history central to a story that is primarily about loss. The prose is addictively brilliant.

The beauty of the book culminates in a wonderful final section that is heartbreaking, and devastating, and perfect. It is a fitting half-farewell (accompanied by Stella Maris, released alongside this book).

Sara Baume: Handiwork (Paperback) 1 star

Missing the craft of writing

1 star

This book wastes space. Baume is telling a story of her relationship to craft, and how (and sort-of why) she makes small sculptural birds. The sparse writing consists of only one or two paragraphs per page. These are sometimes interesting when they deal with personal moments of Baume's contemplative life, but more often they are just regurgitated facts about birds or weather that seem like they were recently read on Wikipedia, or scribbled half-thoughts that were not resolved. In the end the whole book feels self-indulgent, and is really unenjoyable to read.

T. H. White: The Elephant and the Kangaroo (1947, G. P. Putnam's Sons) No rating

Problematic satire

No rating

I don't actually know how to review this obscure TH White novel. It needs three considerations, which I'll divide up below.

First, the novel centres on "Mr White", an English gentleman living in rural Ireland in the 1940s. White himself moved to Ireland as a conscientious objector to WWII, and lived there for some years. In the story, the archangel Michael appears and instructs White and his two Irish hosts to build an ark as a second flood is coming. The story follows the building of the ark, including some interesting pragmatic considerations (what to leave behind, how much food, etc). There is undoubtedly a lot of thinly veiled autobiography in the story, even if it is a satire.

The second consideration is how Irish people are treated by an English writer. Even as a satire, the stereotypes of lazy, violent and stupid rural people are rolled out liberally. While …

Toni Cade Bambara, Toni Cade Bambara: Those bones are not my child (Paperback, 2021, Penguin Random House) 5 stars

Written over a span of twelve years, and edited by Toni Morrison, who calls Those …

An American Epic

5 stars

There are so many things that amazed me about this book, from the intricacy of the characters to the extraordinary storytelling, to the intense depth of the research. But most of all, I was amazed that I had never heard of it or of the Atlanta child murders. Both the book and the murders seem so central to modern Black American history that their invisibility (or erasure) seem deeply poignant.

It took me nine months to read. It is a long book, but it also needed space to read, digest, and understand. Ostensibly, it is a book about a mother looking for her child who has disappeared during the spate of murders of Black children in Atlanta from 1979-81. Zala, the protagonist, becomes an active community member, joining up with other parents of disappeared young Black children who try every avenue possible to find their children. It tells the story …

Carolina Valente Pinto: All the Other Directions We Can Go (EBook, 2023, Institute of Network Cultures) 3 stars

This book analyses the values and processes that characterise DIY (do it yourself) digital infrastructure, …

Documenting a Feminist Server

3 stars

This book explains at the beginning that it is the conversion of a Master's Thesis into a publication, and that is exactly how it reads. It's a good documentation of the project 'A Transversal Network of Feminist Servers' (ATNOFS), which was an EU-wide project where different organisations set up data servers under feminist principles. The documentation goes into detail on how this works, and focuses on how sharing and making space is central to the servers.

It does feel a little light on critique and future considerations, but again this is not unsurprising given its origins.