Los guardianes de la libertad

propaganda, desinformación y consenso en los medios de comunicación de masas

No cover

Noam Chomsky: Los guardianes de la libertad (Spanish language, 1995, Grijalbo Mondadori)

372 pages

Spanish language

Published Aug. 10, 1995 by Grijalbo Mondadori.

ISBN:
978-84-253-2820-6
Copied ISBN!

View on OpenLibrary

4 stars (3 reviews)

8 editions

Review of 'Manufacturing Consent' on 'Goodreads'

5 stars

Despite giving this book 5 stars, I have some criticisms. To its credit, this book is pretty damning with its rebuke of U.S. mainstream media propaganda, and provides exhaustive case studies that back its claims. I do however think some arguments could have been even stronger.

1. The authors (Herman and Chomsky) cite reporting that they themselves don't scrutinize. Namely, reporting from Amnesty International. They do the very thing with Amnesty International that they are accusing the mainstream media of doing with U.S. Government propaganda. They report it without analysis, as if it's fact. I am not claiming that Amnesty International is a bad source. Quite the contrary. I greatly admire the organization (I'd even love to work for them). But the authors should go through the same effort of proving why Amnesty International is providing trustworthy information each time they cite them, just as they did with proving why …

Review of 'Manufacturing Consent' on 'Goodreads'

4 stars

Even though the internet has changed the balance of power in media reporting and information dissemination since the era of the 20th century US gangster imperialism analysed in the work, what has not changed is the liberal intellectuals' and mainstream media organisations' service to causes of the Empire. They have never had potent arguments against Chomsky and others' analyses of their role, and reading about their actions that aided the military-industrial complex's rampant pillaging in the name of global power and corporate profits is important.

avatar for myrmidex

rated it

4 stars

Subjects

  • Medios de comunicación masiva -- Aspectos políticos -- Estados Unidos.
  • World politics -- 1975-1985.
  • Política mundial -- 1975-1985.
  • World politics -- 1985-1995.
  • Política mundial -- 1985-1995.
  • Mass media -- United States -- Objectivity.
  • Medios de comunicación masiva -- Estados Unidos -- Objetividad.
  • Mass media -- Political aspects -- United States.